Monday, August 27, 2007

Relevance of Rudolf Steiner

Hello all,

As I look at the literature on power standards, and standards in
general, I'm struck by the lack of imagination and the overriding
tendency of those compiling and using these "standards," to continue
to package school experiences in the traditional domains of learning
(science, social studies, math, etc.) that have defined education for
so many, many years. I think these standards, and the domains of
learning that they help to reinforce within the educational scene,
effectively isolate students from themselves, from community, from the
natural world, and from spirituality that ultimately defines the
shared and irrevocable existence of all human beings.

I include Rudolph Steiner's contributions from "The Essentials of
Education," and other references to Waldorf education in an effort to
help us develop an understanding of spirituality as well as
materiality in our view of "power standards." I want to encourage us
to consider the education of the whole person as we map our course of
study at ers.

Looking forward to continuing our dialogue and our work together.

Regards,
John

Sunday, August 26, 2007

More links from John

Ann Arbor, MI public schools
http://www.aaps.k12.mi.us/ins.home/ins.curriculum1/ms_power_standards

Rock Island/Milan School district
http://curriculum.risd41.org/committee/best_practices/Power%20Standards.html
http://curriculum.risd41.org/committee/best_practices/index.htm

Montbello High School
Math, reading:
http://montbello.dpsk12.org/stories/storyReader$1744
Social Studies:
http://montbello.dpsk12.org/stories/storyReader$1752

Citrus Hill Hawks
http://www.valverde.edu/chhs/pages/home/standards/index.asp?topic=home&subtopic=standards

Saugus High School
http://www.hartdistrict.org/saugus/power.htm

Waldorf Education
http://www.millennialchild.com/millennialchild/High%20Stakes%20Testing.htm
http://www.wiws.org/AboutWaldorf.htm
http://www.waldorfschoolofcapecod.org/news-bglobe-waldorf-way.htm

Rudolf Steiner's thoughts

The following is from Rudolf Steiner’s, “The Essentials of Education.”

Our task is to work around young people so that they may become beings who imitate goodness, truth, beauty, and wisdom. .. . Education is not something that we work at in isolated activities, but something lived.

Children do not ask intellectually with words, but deep in their hearts. “May I do this?” or, “May I do that?” They will be answered, “Yes, you may,” if the teacher does it. “Should I leave this undone?” “Yes, because my teacher shows that it may be left undone.”

The intellect becomes active in its own way once children reach puberty. It is actually a matter of bringing human beings to the point where they find within themselves what they must understand – draw from their own inner being what was initially given as spontaneous imitation, then as artistic, imaginative activity. Thus, even during the later period, we should not force things on the human being so that there is the least feeling of arbitrary, logical compulsion.

Schiller’s rebuttal to Kant: “I willingly serve my friend, but unfortunately I serve him from inclination; alas, I therefore lack virtue!” (“Duty, you sublime and powerful name—you who bear no enticements but demand stern submission.” Kant)

“Duty—that is, where people love what they tell themselves to do.” Goethe

To educate means to “draw out,” to “lead out.”

Our civilization’s materialistic view has produced an age when human beings pass each other by, because their perceptions are all connected with bodily nature. People cry out for a social life out of the intellect, and at the same time develop in their feelings an asocial indifference toward one another as well as a lack of mutual understanding. Souls who are isolated in individual bodies pass one another by, whereas souls who awaken the spirit within to find spirit itself also find themselves, as human beings, in communion with other human beings. Real community will blossom from the present chaos only when people find the spirit—when, living together in spirit, they find each other.

The great longing of today’s youth is to discover the human being. The youth movement came from this cry. This cry has been transformed into a cry for spirit, through the realization that the human being can be found only when spirit is found; if spirit is lost, we lose one another.

The human being living on earth in body, soul, and spirit can develop out of such knowledge. A worldview can develop into an experience of the cosmos, and the Sun and Moon may be seen in everything that grows and flourishes on Earth. When we educate young people with this kind of background, we will properly develop the experience of immortality, the divine , the eternally religious element in the growing child, and we implant in the child’s being an immortal aspect destined for further progress, which we must carry in spirit through the gate of death.

If people are educated properly on Earth, the heavenly being will also be educated properly, since the heavenly being lives within the earthly being. When we educate the earthly being correctly, we also promote the true development of the heavenly being through the tiny amount of progress that we make possible between birth and death.

In this way we come to terms with a view that progresses, in the true sense, to a universal knowledge—a knowledge that understands the need for human cooperation in the great spiritual cosmos, which is also revealed in the realm of the senses. True education recognizes that human beings are coworkers in building humankind.

From this it follows that we cannot understand the world as a one-sided subject of the head alone. It is untrue to say that we can understand the world through ideas and concepts. And it is equally false to say that world can be understood through feeling alone. It has to be understood through ideas and feeling, as well as through the will; human beings will understand the world only when divine spirit descends into will. Humankind will also be understood then—not through one aspect, but through the whole being. We need a worldview not just for the intellect, but for the whole human being—for human thinking, feeling, and willing—a concept of the world that discovers the world in the human body, soul, and spirit.

Only those who rediscover the world in the human being, and who see the world in human beings, can have a true concept of the world; because just as the visible world is reflected in the eye, the entire human being exists as an eye of spirit, soul, and body, reflecting the whole cosmos. Such a reflection cannot be perceived externally; it must be experienced from within. Then it is not just an appearance, like an ordinary mirrored image; it is an inner reality. Thus, in the process of education, the world becomes human, and the human being discovers the world in the self.

Working in this way in education, we feel that the human race would be disrupted if all human experience were tied to matter, because, when they deny their own being, souls do not find one another but lose themselves. When we move to spirit, we find other human beings. Community, in the true sense of the word, must be established through spirit. Human beings must find themselves in spirit; then they can unite with others. If worlds are to be created out of human actions, then the world must be seen in human beings.


To spend oneself in matter
is to grind down souls.

To find oneself in the spirit
is to unite human beings.

To see oneself in all humanity
is to construct worlds.

John's recommendations for proceeding

Start with the mission statement. Find within the mission statement answers to the following critical questions:

_ Does the mission statement provide a guide for life that endures over time?
_ Does the mission statement give the learner leverage when facing life’s great
challenges?
_ Does the mission statement lead young people toward the next level of learning?

Examples:

. . . to make a difference in the world.

. . . to nurture the intellect, stimulate the will, and embrace the creative potential of youth in a balanced environment that engenders reverence, respect, and responsibility for nature and the needs of others.


Link to power standards:

• Look for alignment of standards with the mission.
• Consider the framework and criteria that will best drive the mission.

Resources and Links shared by John

It's a tedious process to create each link. The first few are linked so you can just click on them, but for the rest you will have to cut and paste the link yourself.

Resources:

Science Content Standards:
http://www.nap.edu/readingroom/books/nses/html/6a.html

Math Standards:
http://www.csdsac.org/Curriculum/math.htm

The Arts:
http://www.nheon.org/frameworks/fine_arts/

The usefulness of Standards:
http://www.ed.gov/pubs/Standards/lessons.html

Victorian Essential Learning Standards:
http://vels.vcaa.vic.edu.au/links/standards.html#3

Social Studies Standards:
http://www.socialstudies.org/standards/introduction/

What’s Working in Standards-Based Education:
http://www.buildingblocks.org/research/index.html

Music Teaching Standards:
http://www.asme.edu.au/ASME_Standards05.pdf.

Service-Learning Alignment With State Standards:
http://www.kwfdn.org/events/high_school/leadership/2002_06/servicelearning.pdf

http://www.crf-usa.org/network/netwk_73.html

http://www.kon.org/S-LP_standards.pdf.

Standards for Integrated Curriculum and Social Responsibility:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Waldorf_education


Culturally Responsive Curriculum Standards:
http://www.ankn.uaf.edu/publications/standards.html

Standards for Spirituality in Education:
http://www.aare.edu.au/06pap/jan06323.pdf.
http://www.leaonline.com/doi/abs/10.1207/S15327582IJPR1303_02